Suspects identified in 2018 Grant County homicide

Published 11:00 am Friday, May 29, 2020

The Grant County Sheriff's Office made an arrest for the homicides of Terry and Sharon Smith, whose remains were whose in 2018 after their cabin burnt down.

JOHN DAY — Closure may be coming almost two years after a couple vanished after their cabin became engulfed in flames in the Laycock Creek Road area.

Grant County District Attorney Jim Carpenter said he planned to prosecute suspects in the murder of Terry and Sharon Smith.

“There are suspects in the case,” Carpenter said, “and a substantial amount of evidence that points to the suspects, such that, I will be taking it to the grand jury.”

Carpenter said he plans to do that as soon as grand juries can meet without social distancing restrictions, and he anticipates an indictment.

The couple and their pickup were not found after their home on Nan’s Rock Road between John Day and Mt. Vernon burned in the early morning hours of July 18, 2018.

The case evolved into a homicide after investigators confirmed DNA samples from remains in the residence belonged to Terry and Sharon Smith. The pickup was later located in Boise.

Carpenter said the Oregon Department of Justice was brought in as a special prosecutor for Grant County, and the DOJ had been directing the investigation and working toward prosecution.

Carpenter said, several months ago, Grant County Sheriff Glenn Palmer requested the case back from the DOJ for prosecution in Grant County.

Because of limited resources, Carpenter said, he attempted to bring in a special prosecutor, a local attorney whom he declined to name, who initially agreed to take the case but then backed out after receiving the materials from the justice department.

“It was initially assigned to the Department of Justice because I simply didn’t have the resources to take care of it,” Carpenter said. “I still don’t, but there are no other options. The Department of Justice isn’t going to take it back.”

Oregon State Police and Grant County Sheriff’s Office are investigating the case with the assistance of the FBI Bend office.

“I’ve discussed the case recently with the FBI, and they are assisting the sheriff’s office with a few final steps in the investigation,” Carpenter said.

Palmer declined to comment in an email on May 14, stating it was “an ongoing criminal investigation.”

Family and friends talked about the social nature of Terry and Sharon Smith and how unusual it would be for them to disappear for any length of time without communicating with their friends and family.

“The Smiths’ friends and acquaintances all would like to know if there has been any progress in solving this heinous murder,” Lisa Roach, a friend of the Smiths, said in an email. “Any news would be greatly appreciated.”

Timothy Williams, a pastor who grew close to the Smiths after purchasing a property from them roughly a year before their deaths, said he was their “hanai son” — a term used in Hawaiian culture to refer to a family member, though not blood-related.

He said Terry and Sharon saw something good in him and treated him like family. He said they were not just people he bought a house from in an agreement of sale.

“I loved these people,” Williams said. “There’s no reason that you can tell me, or anybody can tell me, they deserved to die like they did.”

Marketplace