My Voice: All we want are the facts
Published 6:45 am Tuesday, March 3, 2020
- Hansell
Because my family didn’t have television on the farm for most of my growing up years, it was a special treat to watch TV when I would stay with my grandparents in Walla Walla during the summer. One of my favorite shows was “Dragnet.” Sergeant Joe Friday, played by Jack Webb, was the star.
The best-known quote from the TV series was “All we want are the facts, ma’am.”
Later, comedian Dan Aykroyd shortened it to “Just the facts, ma’am. Just the facts.”
The Oregon Legislature is dealing with a massive bill called cap and trade. What are the facts? Can you get the facts without the political spin? KGW News in Portland reported some facts, which I believe have been lost or ignored in the cap-and-trade discussion. Here are few facts you might find interesting.
Fact No. 1 — Being opposed to the current cap-and-trade bills does not mean you are a “climate change denier.” I and my fellow Republicans have been willing to work on bipartisan bills to address the issue. But at every turn we have been rejected. It is this bill or nothing.
Fact No. 2 — Do the math.
The cap-and-trade legislation is estimated to accrue billions of dollars in increased energy costs, with no measurable reduction in greenhouse gases. Oregon’s produces 65 million metric tons of greenhouse gases per year. The United States produces 6.4 billion metric tons for its annual carbon footprint. Do the math, and Oregon’s contribution is 1%. The entire world’s carbon footprint is 36.8 billion metric tons. Oregon’s part of that is 1/10 of 1%.
Even the proponents of this piece of legislation say Oregon’s contribution to world greenhouse gas emissions is unmeasurable. We are asking Oregon businesses and Oregon citizens to fall on their swords for no measurable result.
“Do the math, ma’am. Do the math.”
Fact No. 3 — Oregon has already passed significant legislation to reduce greenhouse gas emissions: low carbon fuel standard legislation; coal-to-clean legislation; Renewable Energy Portfolio legislation; $2 billion upgrading efficiency through Energy Trust of Oregon, which Oregon ratepayers have funded.
“Do the math, ma’am. Do the math.”
Fact No. 4 — Oregon’s population grew from from 2.8 million in 1990 to 4.2 million today. Over that same period of time, our emissions grew from 56.2 to 64 million metric tons. We experienced a 50% growth in population with only a 15% growth in emissions. Oregon actually has experienced a 22% reduction per capita since 1990 in greenhouse emissions. I believe the facts show that what we have done legislatively is working, and the citizens are already heavily investing in the reduction.
“Do the math, ma’am. Do the math.”
Fact No. 5 — Oregonians are an intelligent lot. To state the cap-and-trade legislation is too complicated for citizens to understand, as my colleagues on the other side of the aisle have done, is insulting. The people of Oregon are intelligent enough to determine for themselves if the proposed cap-and-trade legislation contains the facts they require to cast an affirmative vote.
What is the reason the Democratic majority rejects having the people decide? Could it be the facts aren’t there to support the vote? I certainly think that is the reason.
“All we want are the facts, ma’am.”
Fact No. 6 — The Republican legislators have been trying to get the facts. We have time and time again throughout the process asked questions to try to get the facts.
Question: What are the actual costs of this program? Answer: We don’t have the time or resources to determine it.
Question: Is it a tax? Answer: Don’t think so, but let the courts decide.
Question: Will Oregon businesses have to leave Oregon? Answer: We hope not.
Question: With no measurable impact on either the world’s or the United States’ carbon imprint, why should Oregonians and Oregon companies be required to pay such a massive cost? Answer: We have a moral obligation, and if Oregon leads other states will follow.
“How do you get the facts, ma’am, when there aren’t any to be given?”
In a court of law, both sides present the facts as they see them. Our state Constitution also provides the same format with legislation, where the facts can be presented and debated in the court of public opinion. The citizens of Oregon become the jury that decides the outcome. The cap-and-trade legislation needs to be decided by a vote of the people of Oregon.
To do anything else is wrong. Let the people decide, ma’am, let the people decide.
State Sen. Bill Hansell of Athena is a Republican and in his eighth year serving Senate District 29, which comprises part of Wasco County and all of Gilliam, Morrow, Sherman, Umatilla, Union, and Wallowa counties. Before that, he served as Umatilla County commissioner for 30 years.